- 2018
- Attorney: Kelsey McClain
- Witness: Lillie Stephens
- Witness: Victoria Holder
- 2017
- Witness: Meredith Clement
- Attorney: Jennifer Bitterly, Kelsey McClain
- 2016
- Attorney: Jennifer Bitterly
- Witness: Taylor Jackson
- 2014
- Attorney: Amelia Yeomelakis
- Witness: Elizabeth Ross
- 2013
- Attorney: Matthew Niegos, Mathew Jehl
- Witness: Pauline Dyer
- 2012
- 2011
- Witness: Kashan Pathan, Robbie Cook
- 2010
- Attorney: Steven Strasberg
- 2009
- Attorney: Michael Polovich
- 2008
- Witness: Sean Evins, Johnika Geeter
- 2005
- 2004
- Attorney: Millie Worley, Jon David Willingham
- Witness: Erin Hesli
- 2003
- Witness: Jasmine Crockett
- 2002
- 2001
- Attorney: Dave Adams, Jennifer Keirce
- Witness: Naomi Long, Laura Bauer, Debra Hall
- 2000
- 1999
- Witness: Drew Butler, Hallie Nolen
- 1997
- Witness: Autumn Cartmill, Scott Self
- Attorney: Gina Yannitell
- 1996
- Witness: Tanner Neidhardt
- Attorney: Ryan Feeney
- 1995
- 1995
- Attorney: Ryan Feeney
- Witness: Nikki Holzhauer
- 1994
- Attorney: Karen Jones, Trey Hamilton
- Witness: Eric Dunning
- 1994
- Attorney: Gina Yannitell
- Witness: Andrea Moseley, Kevin Wiley
- 1993
- Attorney: Lisa Mancini
- Witness: Andrea Moseley, Sam Woods
- 1991
- Attorney: Thais Davenport
- Witness: Trent Scofield, Josh Drake
- 1990
- Attorney: Doug Kilday
- Witness: Trent Scofiel
- 1989
- Attorney: Jon Perry, Anthony Pietrangelo
- 1988